I’m listening to NPR news here at the end of the day, and just heard a report that the home of the suicide bomber who blew himself up on a Jerusalem bus yesterday has been demolished by the Israeli Army.
Why? The man himself is dead, and if he had been concerned about abandoning his family to their fate it seems to me he wouldn’t have blown himself up in the first place. It isn’t just locking the barn door behind the horse. It is punishment of those who, whatever their sympathies, are innocent of the act itself. The Talmud says something most often translated as “Justice without mercy is not justice.” The American legal system, and I believe Israel’s, is based on the principal that one is innocent until proven guilty. But the family of a bomber, unless someone has more information than I know about, is only guilty by association – and yet their home has been demolished.
The primary thing this will do is confirm the Palestinian belief that the Israelis, and most of all the Israeli Army, is an instrument of repression and retribution, and that justice is a meanlingless concept when applied to them by Israel. I am reminded of the reports I read from South Africa, toward the end of the era of Apartheid. I was raised to believe that one of the strongest reasons to be proud of my people was that they gave their allegiance to law and justice long before law applied to rulers elsewhere. I was taught that the highest attributes were mercy and peace and the strongest obligation the improvement of the world. Demolishing the home of a terrorist punishes the family, not the man who committed the act no matter how unspeakable that act was. That, to me, is not justice. It does not show mercy; it does not bring peace. It does not improve the world; quite the contrary. It feeds the anger and increases the violence. That is not what I believe my people should be. I hope I’m not the only one for whom it is a shame.